The Daylily Place: Hardy Evergreen Poll


Hardy Daylily Evergreens
Email Robin Poll Results, May 2000
Poll compiled by Charlotte Chamitoff

Submitted by Nancy Oakes, Zone 5:

AFRICAN AMULET,    AFRICAN GRAPE,    APOLLODORUS,    BENCHMARK,    BIRD'S EYE,    CAJUN LADY,    CLARENCE SIMON,    CORFU,    DARK STAR,    DeVAUGHN HODGES,    ETCHED EYES,    EXCITABLE,    EZEKIAL,    GLENDEVON,    HEAVENLY HAVILAND,    HIGH NOON,    IDA'S MAGIC,    JAN'S TWISTER,    JASON SALTER,    JOYFUL OCCASION,    KING'S CLOAK,    LADY LIMELIGHT,    LENOX,    LITTLE DEEKE,    MAE GRAHAM,    MILLIE SCHLUMF,    MING PORCELAIN,    MOLINO LIMELIGHT,    MOSCOW SPRING,    MOUNTAIN VIOLET,    NEON PINK,    NIGHT BEACON,    NILE PLUM,    PAINTED LADY,    PANDORA'S BOX,    PEACOCK MAIDEN,    PIPPIN'S MAGIC,    PLAYBOY,    POINTSETTIA LOVE,    RED RIBBONS,    RESPIGHI,    ROSE PETTICOAT,    ROSELLA SHERIDAN,    RUFFLED PINAFORE,    RUSSIAN EASTER,    SALMON SHEEN,    SANFORD DOUBLE VIOLET,    SECRET SPLENDOR,    SWEET THOUGHTS,    THY TRUE LOVE,    TIME LORD,    VELVET BUTTERFLY,    VICTORIAN DAYS,    WIND FRILLS,    WINDOW DRESSING,    WISTERIA,   
Submitted by: Marifran here in Goshen, CT Zone 5, Region 4
Here are my hardy evergreens. My Zone 5 is really more like Zone 4 most years too. The evergreens always have foliage damage in the spring but they rapidly grow out of it. And these listed have never had spring sickness here. I will be interested in the results of your survey. I still prefer the dormants because they don't look as messy in the spring. But if we have a cold spring, which we usually do, by the time I get outside, the evs are beginning to grow out of the damaged foliage.


BENCHMARK, Munson
CLEO (registered ev but dor here)
EVELYN LELA STOUT , Munson
HEADY WINE, Peck
JAN'S TWISTER - Joiner, J '91
PANDORA'S BOX - Talbott '82
PERSIAN MARKET - Munson '69
RED RIBBONS Lenington G '64
RUE MADELAINE - Carr '92
SULTRY SIREN - Gates '91
VICTORIA ELIZABETH BARNES - Munson '77
Submitted by Ian Sanderson, Zone 3:
These plants have been with me in Edmonton, Zone 3, for three or more years. I don't mulch anything, but generally we get a foot or so of consistent snow cover. We have had a couple winters recently where there was no snow til about New Year's; no significant losses. Not all these plants are suitable for our short season and cold nights. Currently about 150 of my thousand odd hems are registered as EV; a number are not old enough to assess.


ALEC ALLEN, 26 EM 5.5 EV '82 CARPENTER K.
APOLLODORUS, 28 ML 4.5 EV '85 MUNSON
AZTEC EVERGREEN, 20 EE 4.5 EV Unreg.
BARONET'S BADGE , 30 EM 5.0 EV '84 MUNSON
BENCHMARK, 30 M 6.0 EV '82 MUNSON
BIRD'S EYE , 20 EE 3.5 EV '86 KIRCHHOFF
BLACK PLUSH, 32 M 7.0 EV '56 CONNELL
BLUSHING PARFAIT, 18 M 4.5 EV '83 SPALDING
BREAKFAST AT TIFFANY'S, 30 M 6.0 EV '87 MUNSON
CAMEROONS, 28 M 5.0 EV '88 MUNSON
CAT'S CRADLE, 38 EM 8.0 EV '87 HAGER
CHINESE TEMPLE FLOWER, 24 EM 5.0 EV '80 MUNSON I.
CHORUS LINE, 20 E 2.5 EV '81 KIRCHHOFF
CINDY MARIE, 28 EM 6.0 EV '79 DURIO
COUNTRY PRIDE, 28 E 5.0 EV '89 JOINER
COURT MAGICIAN, 26 EM 5.0 EV '88 MUNSON
DARK STAR, 32 EM 6.0 EV '53 CONNELL
DIXIE LAND BAND, 20 E 7.0 EV '69 FLEISHEL
EMPEROR'S DRAGON, 26 M 5.0 EV '88 MUNSON
ENDURING LOVE, 23 EM 8.0 EV '88 BROWN B.
EYED RADIANCE, 25 M 5.7 EV '88 CARPENTER J.
EZEKIEL, 28 M 5.0 EV '92 TALBOTT
FORSYTH LEMON DROP, 24 EE 3.5 EV '86 LEFEVER
GERTRUDE CONDON, 22 EM 5.0 EV '66 WHEELER
GLENDEVON, 30 EM 6.0 EV '86 MUNSON
GRACEFUL EYE, 21 E 6.0 EV '81 SPALDING
GRACELAND, 28 E 6.0 EV '89 MORSS
GREEN DOLPHIN STREET, 28 EM 7.5 EV '87 ROBERTS S.
HARBOR BLUE, 26 EM 7.5 EV '62 LAKE
HOT WIRE, 30 EM 6.0 EV '87 STAMILE
INNER VIEW, 26 EE 6.5 EV '84 MORSS
IRISH ELF, 14 EM 2.2 EV '78 HUDSON
JASON SALTER, 18 EM 2.7 EV '87 SALTER E.H.
JOAN SENIOR, 25 EM 6.0 EV '78 DURIO
JOLYENE NICHOLE, 14 M 6.0 EV '84 SPALDING
KATE CARPENTER, 28 EM 6.0 EV '80 MUNSON
KELLY'S GIRL, 19 M 5.7 EV '83 SPALDING
LADY MISCHIEF, 18 EM 3.0 EV '81 HUDSON
LITTLE BIG MAN, 16 EM 2.7 EV '79 CRUSE
LITTLE DEEKE, 20 EE 4.0 EV '80 GUIDRY
LITTLE PINK SLIPPERS, 16 EM 2.5 EV '79 CRUSE
LITTLE SHOWOFF, 16 E 2.7 EV '72 WILLIAMSON
LOUDER STILL, 22 EM 6.0 EV '84 GATES
MARSE CONNELL, 38 M 7.5 EV '52 CONNELL
METAPHOR, 22 EM 5.0 EV '83 GATES
MIDNIGHT MAGIC, 28 EM 5.5 EV '80 KINNEBREW
MILLIE SCHLUMPF, 20 EE 6.0 EV '81 GUIDRY
MING PORCELAIN, 28 E 5.2 EV '82 KIRCHHOFF
MOONLIGHT MIST, 18 M 3.0 EV '82 HUDSON
MOUNTAIN VIOLET, 28 M 5.0 EV '73 MUNSON
MY BELLE, 26 E 6.5 EV '75 DURIO
NAGASAKI, 19 E 4.5 EV '79 KIRCHHOFF
NIECE BEVERLY, 15 M 6.5 EV '85 SPALDING
NIGHT BEACON, 27 EM 4.0 EV '89 HANSEN
OBSESSED, 24 E 6.0 EV '88 GATES
OUACHITA BEAUTY, 36 EM EV '55 PITTARD
PANDORA'S BOX , 19 EM 4.0 EV '82 TALBOTT
PEACH JUBILEE, 29 EM 7.0 EV '87 BELCHER
PEACOCK MAIDEN, 31 M 9.5 EV '82 CARPENTER K.
PERSIAN MARKET, 27 M 7.0 EV '69 MUNSON
PIPPIN'S MAGIC, 28 EM 5.0 EV '87 MUNSON
PIRATE'S PATCH, 28 EM 6.0 EV '92 SALTER
RAINBOW SPANGLES, 30 EM 7.0 EV '84 TEMPLE
RED RIBBONS, 42 M 8.0 EV '65 LENINGTON
ROSE JOY, 22 M 6.5 EV> '84 CARPENTER K.
ROSIE MEYER, 32 E 5.5 EV '57 ALEXANDER
ROYAL ELK, 36 E 6.2 EV '58 LAKE
ROYAL EVENTIDE, 28 E 5.0 EV '86 KIRCHH
OFF ROYAL SARACEN, 26 EM 6.0 EV '82 MUNSON
RUSSIAN EASTER, 30 M 6.0 EV '92 KIRCHHOFF
SAVOY, 26 EM 5.0 EV '86 MUNSON
SCARLET ORBIT, 22 E 6.0 EV '84 GATES
SEDUCTOR, 18 EE 6.0 EV '83 GATES
SIAMESE ROYALTY, 24 EM 5.0 EV '80 MUNSON
SILVER VEIL , 28 EM 5.0 EV '77 MUNSON
SO EXCITED , 20 EM 5.5 EV '87 HANSEN
SPANISH MASQUERADE , 22 EM 7.0 EV '83 MUNSON
SPIDER SPIRITS , 40 M 7.5 EV '87 BROWN B
SQUIRRELY SHIRLEY, 15 EM 4.5 EV '84 CRUSE
SUGAR COOKIE, 21 EM 3.2 EV '83 APPS
THAIS, 30 EM 6.0 EV '78 MUNSON
THEBES, 30 M 5.0 EV '85 MUNSON
TIMELESS FIRE, 18 EM 5.2 EV '86 GUIDRY
TONIA GAY, 15 M 5.5 EV '84 SPALDING
VINTAGE BORDEAUX , 27 E 5.7 EV> '87 KIRCHHOFF
VINTAGE WINE, 32 EM 6.0 EV '76 MUNSON
WAYNE JOHNSON, 28 M 5.5 EV '84 HUDSON
WHOOPEREE, 24 E 6.5 EV '86 GATES
WILDFIRE TANGO, 26 EE 6.0 EV '93 KIRCHHOFF
WIND FRILLS , 34 EM 7.0 EV '78 TARRANT
WISTFUL MOMENT, 22 E 6.0 EV '79 GUIDRY
Submitted by Gloriana Clark USDA Zone 5:

CANADIAN BORDER PATROL
CHANCE ENCOUNTER
FARMER'S DAUGHTER
GAUCHO
HOT EMBER (very hardy--gret Stamile orange)
MIDNIGHT MAGIC
ROYAL HEIRESS
SEBASTIAN
YESTERDAY MEMORIES
Submitted by Maurice Dow, Zone 5:
We list quite a few evergreens in our Irish Lilyput Daylily catalogue. I'm not sure if you have received a copy. In any case these are some of the cultivars that have grown in our zone 5 garden.I will probably be able to add greatly to the list as I have close to a 100 that I have only had for two years and will be able to check their hardiness this spring.

Two things to note; the breeder may find that a particular variety is evergreen in their garden in the southern US and we find that in fact it is a dormant in our climate.

The other is that many dormants and semi-evergreens are not hardy in our climate.

We find that daylilies should always be planted in the spring in our climate. This is especially true for the evergreens.


BENCHMARK,  BOOGER,  CHINESE TEMPLE FLOWER,  COYOTE MOON,  DARLING DEICER ,  ELSIE SPALDING,  ENCHANTED RAINBOW,  FLIRTY EDNA ,  FRANK GLADNEY,  GLENDEVON,  GUINIVER'S GIFT,  JUNGLE MASK ,  MEADOW SPRITE ,  MERRY WITCH,  MIDNIGHT MAGIC,  MING PORCELAIN,  NEW SNOW,  PANDORA'S BOX,  PICADILLY PRINCESS,  PINK CHAPEAU,  PUSHMATAHA,  ROSIE ISAK ,  SEBASTIAN,  SNOWED IN ,  STUDY IN SCARLET,  SUGAR COOKIE,  TUSCAWILLA DAVE TALBOTT,  VINO DI NOTTE,  VINTAGE BORDEAUX,  WILL RETURN,  ZINFANDEL
Submitted by Julie Gridley, Zone 3-4:
Sorry this is so late, but I simply didn't have time to contribute to this poll till after Easter. Anyway, here's a list of evergreens that have survived for me up here at the border of zones 3 and 4 in central Wisconsin. I actually didn't have as many evergreens as I thought - but almost all the ones I do have are doing fine. Several are Munson's, however, and he was known for breeding hardy evergreens. I have more trouble with many of the semi-evergreens I have. Maybe that will be the subject of a future poll! Thanks for your work on this one.


BENCHMARK
BEST KEPT SECRET
CEE TEE
FRANK GLADNEY (I hesitate to add this one because others have written that it is tender for them in even warmer zones than mine. I've only had it a few years and so far, so good - but perhaps a bad winter would do it in)
FRENCH PAVILION
JOAN SENIOR
KECIA
MING PORCELAIN
SALZBURG
TRUDY HARRIS
Submitted by Steve Deming, Zone 5:
Several of these are listed as SEV but behave as Evergreens


Maylaysian Monarch (Munson)
Mendosino (Morss)
Matisse (Munson)
Leeba Orange Crush (Gates)
Submitted by Joan Messer, Zone 3:
I hope that all of these are registered as evergreen ... I used Eureka and catalogues of the hybridizers where I could.


AUGUST MORN (J. Carpenter) I had this one for several years and it's wonderful. It also opens very well even on cool mornings. I added it's sibling SEASIDE SUNRISE last year and it looks like it's just as vigorous.

LONG STOCKING (P. Stamile) I planted this one in 1998 and it's the first daylily to start growing in the spring and absolutely the last one around in the fall. It's foliage appears to be very resistant to frost.

DIZZY DOTS (R. Mercer) This one was planted in the fall of 1997 and I was a little nervous about it's survival chances, but it has proven to be very hardy.

ROMEO IS BLEEDING (T. Petit) Planted a couple of years ago, this one is doing well. It does like warmer mornings to open well though.

PASSION DISTRICT (B. Carr) Planted just last fall, but it's up and growing vigorously.

GERDA BROOKER (M. Morss) Planted last spring and it looks great this spring.

RAGS TO RICHES (B. Carr) Planted last spring as well, has increased and looks very healthy this year.

EZEKIEL (Talbott) I've had this one 2 or 3 years now. Grows very well and increases nicely.

TROPICAL EXPERIENCE (P. Stamile) This one was planted in 1998 and handles my extreme temperatures very well.

ROSY SCENARIO (J. Weston) Planted last fall and looks great.

LINDA DANIEL (D. Kirchhoff) Planted last spring and it's doing wonderfully. It bloomed last year, tried to re-bloom and has increased.

MINSTREL'S DAUGHTER (T. Petit) Planted last year. This one was up way ahead of most, frost at night didn't bother it all. Nice increase as well.

DESTINED TO SEE (L. Grace) Planted last spring ...... this one has quite a story behind it, but the end result is that it can put adversity behind it (I usually can kill most things if I set my mind to it!) and survive my winter. Now 4 fans!

EARLY TO BED (M. Kaskel) Once again this is a new one for me. Although it didn't bloom last year, it's thriving now ...... excellent foliage.

QUOTE THE RAVEN (T. Petit) I've had this one for a couple of years. It really came into it's own last year. I find that some take a year or two to adjust.

BROWN EYED GIRL (D. Kirchhoff) This is definitely a hardy one from David Kirchhoff. Winter doesn't seem to bother it at all.

WILDEST DREAMS (J. Temple) Planted last spring, didn't bloom but there was excellent increase and the fans look in excellent shape.

EXPANDING UNIVERSE (T. Petit) This one is my kind of color ..... has cinnamon in it! It looks great this spring.

SUNSHINE AMBER (Sellers) Once again my kind of colors ... good increase and good foliage.

COBALT DAWN (P. Stamile) Planted last spring, bloomed and tried to rebloom as well. It increased and looks great this spring.

ROUGE AND LACE (M. Kaskel) Planted last year. This spring the fans are small, but I haven't given up hope as it often takes some plants a year or two to settle in and adjust.

GLADYS CAMPBELL (T. Petit) A double that I've had for a couple of years. The fans look fat and husky this spring.

CALAIS (W. Munson) I like this one! Planted last year and it's up and doing great this spring. Foliage looks good and there was increase.

DRIPPING WITH GOLD (T. Petit) Planted in 1999, doing well, but not quite as vigorous as some of the others. Perhaps it needs more time.

FREQUENT COMMENT (J. Rice) Acquired in 1998. I divided it to share last year and I see it's coming up this spring with increase.

LEROY (D. Kirchhoff) Planted in the spring of 1999. Nice hot color! Looks great this spring.

ALL FIRED UP (P. Stamile) Planted last year. How can you tell what colors I like! Bloomed and increase for this spring as well.

ETERNITY'S SHADOW (T. Petit) A little slower to start in the spring, but it does catch up to the rest and looks great.

CARIBBEAN DOUBLE CINNAMON (Talbott) I've had this one 3 years now I think. It's consistently double and the color is what pleases me especially.

CALYPSO SUNSET (T. Petit) I know I keep saying I don't like doubles, but here's another one that I do like. Not a fast increaser, but the plant always looks good in the spring.

SECRET SPLENDOR (J. Salter) I've had this one for 3 or 4 years. Increase is slow, but it looks terrific in bloom. I like it! I guess you can't have it all in Zone 3!
Submitted by Carolyn Bidwell, Zone 5b:

CAMEROONS-wonderful
JOAN SENIOR-wonderful
PANDORA'S BOX-shows some sping damage but recovers
Submitted by Don Church, Zone 5:

I would like to add some hardy EVs to your list. Hansen's TUSCAWILLA BLACKOUT, LAST FLIGHT OUT, STORM SURF , planted last year returned with no snow cover to speak of (blown clean by the winds). All came back strong after blooming til frost. GEORGIA O'KEEFFE, CLAIRAVOYANT LADY, in Lincoln just moved here to the coast last week but had snow cover there. Evs not hardy in Blue Hill zone 5 COME SEE, wilsons EMERALDS AND GOLD, CHERRIES FLAMBE, BETTY JENKINS. Apps EARLY ELEGANCE all haven't returned as yet.
Submitted by Charlotte Chamitoff, Zone 4b:

AUGUST MORN, Carpenter,Jack - vigorous and healthy "big" fans tho' increase is slow.

BETTY WARREN WOODS, Munson - from 2 to 4 fans (so far) 2nd year

BLACKJACK CHERRY, Carr - good increase, super looking hem, a favorite

KOKOPELLI'S LUCK, Kirchhoff - good increase

MAGE QUEST, Salter - fans look fine but no increase yet (2nd yr)

MAGIC CARPET RIDE, Kirchhoff - a bit slow to increase

MATISSE, Munson - good increase

MING PORCELAIN, Kirchhoff - good increase- excellent performer, a favorite

MY DARLING CLEMENTINE, Salter - still alive but very slow and no increase

NIGHT BEACON, Hansen - good increase

PANDORA'S BOX, Talbott - good increase

PRINCESS ELLEN, Chrochet - amazing increase of fans on this one

RED RIBBONS, Lenington - vigorous and fast to increase

TENNIS BRACELET, Carr - thought I'd lost it last summer but alas it's 3 fans this yr and looking good.

WILL RETURN, Spalding - Gorgeous flower and good increaser, a favorite

WIND FRILLS, Tarrant - 5 fans in 3rd yr and hoping it performs this season. Slow.
[Return to Top]
Return to List of Daylily Polls    Return to the Daylily Place home page

The opinions expressed by contributors to these pages are solely those of the individual writers and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the account owner.

Revised last on 26 January 2001.

© Copyright 2001 by James E. Shields. All rights reserved.